what is the difference between picky eating and arfid

November 14, 2023

Picky eating and Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) are related terms that describe different levels of challenges related to eating behaviors, particularly in children. Picky eating refers to a common behavior where children have a limited range of preferred foods, often refusing to try new foods or showing strong food preferences. On the other hand, ARFID is a more severe condition characterized by extreme selectivity in food choices, avoidance of certain food textures or smells, and significant weight loss or nutritional deficiencies. Both picky eating and ARFID can have a significant impact on a person’s health and well-being, but ARFID poses a greater risk due to its potential to cause malnutrition and impair growth and development. It is crucial to address these challenges early on and seek appropriate support to ensure a healthy relationship with food and promote overall well-being.

  Picky Eating 

Picky eating, also known as selective eating, is a common phase that many children go through as they develop their taste preferences and explore new foods. It is estimated that up to 50-70% of children experience picky eating at some point during their early years (Dovey et al., 2008). Picky eating is typically characterized by a child’s caution or hesitancy when it comes to trying new foods or certain textures, flavors, or smells. This phase plays a crucial role in shaping a child’s food preferences and can have long-lasting effects on their eating habits and overall nutrition.

  1.   Limited Food Preferences:   Picky eaters, individuals who are selective about their food choices, often display a strong preference for specific foods and may be hesitant to try new ones. They tend to stick to a limited range of familiar foods, opting for what they feel comfortable with and avoiding unfamiliar or unfamiliar-looking options. This behavior can stem from various factors, such as sensory sensitivities, aversions to certain textures or flavors, or a general fear of the unknown when it comes to food. Understanding and addressing the underlying reasons behind picky eating can help foster a more varied and balanced diet for individuals with these preferences.
  1.   Neophobia:   Food neophobia, commonly known as a fear of new foods, is a phenomenon that affects picky eaters. These individuals often exhibit caution when it comes to trying unfamiliar foods, particularly if the appearance deviates from what they are accustomed to. This fear can stem from various factors such as sensory sensitivity or a negative prior experience, making the exploration of new flavors a challenging task for them.
  2.   Typically Mild:  Picky eating is a common behavior among children, which usually resolves itself over time as they develop a more adventurous palate and become open to trying new foods. As they grow and explore different tastes and textures, their food choices tend to expand, leading to a more varied and balanced diet. It’s important for parents to provide a supportive and encouraging environment during this phase, offering a wide range of nutritious options and patiently introducing new flavors to help foster healthy eating habits in the long run.
  3.   Minimal Health Impact:   While picky eating can raise concerns about nutritional variety, it generally does not lead to severe nutritional deficiencies, weight loss, or growth impairment. However, it is important to note that promoting a diverse and balanced diet can help ensure optimal nutrition and overall well-being. Encouraging exposure to a wide range of foods and providing a supportive eating environment can gradually expand a picky eater’s palate and promote a healthier relationship with food.

  Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID)  

Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) is a highly debilitating eating disorder that surpasses the boundaries of typical picky eating. It encompasses substantial difficulties associated with food consumption, frequently leading to insufficient nutrition, weight loss, or impaired growth. According to a study conducted by Thomas et al. (2017), individuals with ARFID are at risk of experiencing long-term impacts on their physical and mental well-being, highlighting the critical need for early intervention and comprehensive treatment strategies.

  1.   Severe Food Restriction:   IIndividuals with Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) experience an intense aversion towards a wide variety of foods, including specific textures, smells, or sensory aspects associated with eating. As a result, their dietary choices become severely limited, leaving them with a narrow range of accepted foods. This condition can significantly impact their overall nutritional intake and quality of life. It is important to understand the complexities and challenges that individuals with ARFID face when it comes to their relationship with food and eating.
  1.   Weight Loss or Growth Impairment:   Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) can cause significant weight loss or growth issues in individuals. This occurs as a result of inadequate caloric intake and nutritional deficiencies stemming from a persistent avoidance or restriction of certain foods. These limitations can impact overall health and well-being, underscoring the importance of early identification and appropriate interventions.
  1.   Medical and Psychological Factors:   Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) can be influenced by various medical factors, including gastrointestinal issues and sensory sensitivities. Additionally, psychological factors such as anxiety and trauma can also contribute to the development and maintenance of ARFID. Understanding these complex interplays between medical and psychological aspects is crucial in addressing and managing ARFID effectively.
  1.   Disruption of Daily Life:   Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) can significantly impact a person’s social life, family dynamics, and overall quality of life due to the severe limitations it imposes on various food-related activities. This includes not only the challenges faced in finding suitable food options but also the potential isolation and discomfort experienced in social gatherings and events centered around food. The unique struggles and complexities associated with ARFID can have far-reaching effects on an individual’s emotional well-being, relationships, and day-to-day functioning, making it crucial to raise awareness and provide support for those affected.
  1.   Professional Intervention:  Individuals with Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) often require comprehensive intervention from a multidisciplinary team of healthcare professionals. This team may include medical doctors, registered dietitians, therapists specializing in eating disorders, and psychologists. The collaborative approach aims to address both the physical and psychological aspects of the disorder, ensuring a holistic and personalized treatment plan for individuals with ARFID.

In summary, picky eating is a relatively common phase that many children go through and usually resolves over time. It is characterized by a limited range of food preferences and may cause temporary mealtime challenges. On the other hand, Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) is a more severe and persistent eating disorder. Children and adults with ARFID experience significant food restrictions, leading to weight loss and sometimes impairment in daily functioning. This disorder often involves sensory sensitivities, fear of adverse consequences, and anxiety surrounding food. Have a younger child and concerned for ARFID? Be sure to review the Feeding Questionnaire and read up on my Picky Eating vs PFD article as well! It’s important to distinguish between picky eating and ARFID, and if you suspect that someone is struggling with ARFID, it is crucial to seek professional help for proper diagnosis and treatment.

Don't miss out!

Sign up to our newsletter and get all our latest recipes & exclusive offers.